On Halo, WoW
However, I see this as hypocritical. Halo has broadened the consumer base for video games, and should be appluaded for that. Further, the game is fun, playable, and has contributed to the future of gaming design. While we praise Nintendo's Wii for bringing new gamers, how can we simultaneously bemoan the growth created by Halo (and its sequel(s)). Just because Halo brought the annoying high school jocks to gaming, and not your best bud down at the comic shop and not your little 8-year-old cousin and not her middle-aged mother, doesn't mean it's a bad game. Can we just back up from the "it's not as good as its sales numbers suggest" track and admit that it's pretty damn good?
Pros: Innovative grenade combat, easy-to-use multiplayer, accessible controls and gameplay, fun.
WoW has a similar problem. Players love it, the press loves it, and record numbers of Earthians love it. However, traditional gamers look down on it. They say the game is addictive, perhaps purposefully, and turns normal people into the undead (whether or not they chose that in-game race). I say it's a damn good game that has defined the way every other future MMO will be designed.
Pros: Depth of content, near perfect group combat, variety of play styles, accessibility.
I think if you distance yourself from the emotional reaction these two games elicit, it is difficult to argue that they are not very well-designed games, and should be lauded as such.
Or maybe I've just played a lot of both, and I'm just talking emotionally.