Friday, May 18, 2007

On Halo, WoW




Blizzard's World of Warcraft and Bungie's Halo are both tremendously popular games. However, despite their (extreme) commercial success, both have met with some resistance from the more traditional gaming community.


However, I see this as hypocritical. Halo has broadened the consumer base for video games, and should be appluaded for that. Further, the game is fun, playable, and has contributed to the future of gaming design. While we praise Nintendo's Wii for bringing new gamers, how can we simultaneously bemoan the growth created by Halo (and its sequel(s)). Just because Halo brought the annoying high school jocks to gaming, and not your best bud down at the comic shop and not your little 8-year-old cousin and not her middle-aged mother, doesn't mean it's a bad game. Can we just back up from the "it's not as good as its sales numbers suggest" track and admit that it's pretty damn good?


Pros:
Innovative grenade combat, easy-to-use multiplayer, accessible controls and gameplay, fun.
Cons: You're forced to interact with the type of people whom your hatred of got you into gaming in the first place. [epic sentence maneuver]


WoW has a similar problem. Players love it, the press loves it, and record numbers of Earthians love it. However, traditional gamers look down on it. They say the game is addictive, perhaps purposefully, and turns normal people into the undead (whether or not they chose that in-game race). I say it's a damn good game that has defined the way every other future MMO will be designed.


Pros: Depth of content, near perfect group combat, variety of play styles, accessibility.
Cons: Too accessible, purposefully labryinth-like depth of content with Vegas-like incentives to keep playing.


I think if you distance yourself from the emotional reaction these two games elicit, it is difficult to argue that they are not very well-designed games, and should be lauded as such.


Or maybe I've just played a lot of both, and I'm just talking emotionally.

Folklore

Okay. So we don't have a budget here at TheNakedGamer, and the mailman keeps stealing all the review copies developers keep sending us. So we don't really get to play all that many brand new games, simply because that would be impractical.

What we do get to do is read about them, and what I'm reading about Game Republic's Folklore is pretty awesome. Apparently, you're some sort of evil Kirby, sucking powers from your defeated foes, except way more awesome than I've made that sound. (Or, more accurately, one of two different power-sucking-heroes, since the game is said to have two playable characters, in the Dante/Virgil tradition (Yes, these guys made DMC)).



This news is coming with Sony's recent Gamer's Day, which I hear has been pretty much the success E3 was always supposed to be. My take on the situation is this: E3 had the potential to be a productive marketing force, but its taste for the show portion of tradeshow overwhelmed its potential for profit. Sony's recent effort gave us more games and less glitz, possibly in response to the God of War 2 European Fiasco, possibly because they didn't need the glitz to get attention because they didn't have to compete with Nintendo, Microsoft, etc. for this week's limelight.

I'm looking forward to more of these smaller events. Not only can they deliver more content when they aren't concerned with trying to top the showmanship of their neighbor's booth, but it also means my calendar isn't quite so E3-centric.

Blizzard Announcement is Coming!!

Tomorrow's the big day: we're going to get an announcement! An announcement that Blizzard will start work on a new product! Aren't we lucky!

I should start this same sort of tradition: announcing that I will announce that I will start work on something.

1up.com has some interesting polls about what gamers want from this new announcement. Apparently, gamers are really really stupid. 23% of respondents want level-gaining heroes in Starcraft 2? WHAT? That's pretty much the one thing they could do to make Starcraft 2 unbuyable. (Of course, I lie: nothing would make Starcraft 2 unbuyable).

23% of respondents in another poll question said that they'd like to see a spinoff of Starcraft that takes a new direction: real-time-strategy. Imagine that! More people want to see an RTS version of Starcraft than an RPG, an FPS, an MMO, or anything else of that sort. Fascinating.

So it's called Medusa, and there are questions of what that means. Kerrigan makes a Medusa-like reference in Starcraft, and Diablo has Medusa references. The Lost Vikings may have Medusa references in the parts of the game that are too difficult to ever get to.

So, let's just say I'm on the edge of my seat, and can't wait to hear what's up in South Korea. World of Lost Vikings, ftw.

Wednesday, May 16, 2007

Oh, internet!

So many posts on message boards I frequent were requesting a dump of Etrian Odyssey that I felt I should speak out. Etrian Odyssey is the kind of niche game that NEEDS the support of those interested in it if it ever hopes to make a profit or impact. And I let them know that, that if they enjoy it is their duty to BUY it and support it.
I got called a fag.

I hope that says more about people who frequent certain message boards than it does about gamers in general. I mean, obviously the majority of gamers aren't pirates. I'd bet most people wouldn't know how to even begin going about pirating, which is a good thing.
But what does it mean when arguably the most dedicated group of people in gaming refuse to provide monetary support to projects that, arguably, need it most?


I suppose I'm not much better. I wait til a game gets as cheap as possible before I buy it, usually, so it isn't like that really contributes to the sales numbers.

Beta Blues

I need a weapon,

As you may have guessed, I am not the biggest fan of Halo. While a good, well-made game, I believe it gets far too much love from the gaming community. The hype behind the Xbox's flagship franchise is unbelievable, matched only by the voraciousness with which the fans consume it. Plenty of worthy games get tragically ignored due to Microsoft's marketing machine.

The series does deserve some credit. For making grenades accessible and important in combat Bungie will forever have my gratitude. While it did not originate vehicles in shooters, it did popularize them. Halo also greatly furthered the cause of bringing FPSes to consoles, a worthy goal started by Goldeneye.

However, this does not excuse its many faults. The story and setting are generic B-movie sci-fi fluff that fails in every attempt to be taken seriously. The characters are boring and even unlikable, especially Master Chief (generic space marine...IN SPACE!) The single-player level design is terribly repetitive and monotonous, which only serves to artificially extend play time. I would go on, but I did not start this post to complain.

This is an admission that I am actually looking forward to Halo 3. I am sure a lot of my issues will not be addressed in this last installment, but I would like to give it a shot. From the beta impressions, it seems like the weapons have become more powerful/enemies die more easily, which was one of my gripes with the other games. The control scheme seems to have been revamped to allow easier gun/grenade switching and reloading. Little icons appear whenever you do something cool (post-death grenade kill, melee kill, multiple foe kill, sticking, laser kill etc) which will hopefully be recorded for a more robust ranking/stat tracking system.

So yeah. I'm not won over yet, but I have a feeling there is some Halo in my future.

He never gets me anything,
Cortana

Monday, May 14, 2007

Hydro Dynamo

Singing in the rain

I love water effects. Always have. Sometimes I'll stop playing a game for a few minutes to just watch a river or a waterfall, becoming almost hypnotized by the ripples and reflections. Sometimes I do this in real life too, commenting on the quality of the shaders or refraction, much to the confusion of my companions.



However, games still have a long way to go. While a game like Bioshock may feature stunning water effects, I doubt there will be the inclusion of hydro-dynamic physics; there does not seem to be much manipulation. I am still waiting for a game where I can take a large bucket, go to a lake, scoop up some water, lose some as it sloshes back and forth, throw it down a flight of stairs, watch it realistically flow and pool at the bottom. I have no idea how feasible this would be with today's technology, but we seem to have a pretty good handle on solids and gases. No, Mario Sunshine doesn't count, as the water evaporates too quickly.

Bioshock looks really good,
Warren Spector

Sunday, May 13, 2007

The Uncanny Valley

Originally used to describe robotics, the "Uncanny Valley" is a term used to describe the odd behavior of humans and human-like technology. For ages, humans have been creating replicas of themselves (such as dolls, statues, paintings, robots, and video game characters). The degree to which these replicas have actually replicated human form has obviously varied significantly. Logically, the more precise the representation, the more the audience can identify with the replica--to a point.

Fascinating stuff happens when the replica gets to the "not quite human" phase, and essentially, the audience is disgusted by the result.
This happened to me while watching an ad for the PS3's "most realistic baseball sim ever". A real batter faces off against a pitcher from the game, and we're supposed to believe that they don't realize they are in different levels of reality. However, the sight of the pitchers heavily detailed face was just appalling.
Not the same ad (mine had a close up of a pitcher's scowling face):




Am I the only one who finds the Wii Sports pitching motions much more appealing than the PS3 version? The uncanny valley--home of zombies and Frankenstein's monster--seems a perfect home for these characters.